Over at his Yankee Sailor blog, Chris Avery has a bit up about a proposal to revise the Sailor’s Creed. Well intended, I’m sure, and great good fun for them as go in for such things. For his own part, your humble scribe always considered the Oath of Office the next-best-thing to divinely inspired, and containing within it all things necessary for secular devotion.
About the best you can say for top-down directed credos are that they permit the officious an opportunity to preach to the disinterested. We don’t change lives through “teachable moments” nearly so much as we might hope. Acta, non verba.
“We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, therefore, is not an act, but a habit.” — Aristotle
I had a knife-in-the-teeth department head when I was a squadron CO who finished a brief for a high risk strike against a well-defended target thus: “Hot work ahead of us, but there’s nothing here we can’t handle with speed and violence.” The air wing commander was so enamored of this brief distillation of the warrior ethos that “Speed and Violence” became the air wing motto – I believe it is to this day. (We’re all about brevity in the fleet air arm. Soul of wit. Also helps to keep the bad guys from getting a fix on you.)
Still, if it’s a creed that’s called for, I rather prefer the version Chris has on his sidebar:
I am a United States Sailor, and a Warrior first. I fight under the Red, White and Blue of my Fathers and descend from the line of Jones, Decatur and Perry. In my ears rings “I have not yet begun to fight” and “Don’t give up the ship”, and in my veins flows Fire and Gunpowder.
I will master my profession and demand that my fellow Sailors master theirs. I will follow when led, and lead when able. I will place nothing above the welfare of my fellow Sailors, save my Mission, and no matter what my ship, squadron, station or watch, I will help deliver Defeat to the Enemy.
With Honor in my deeds, Courage in my heart, and Commitment in my hands, I will do my duty until Victory is in hand and Liberty is secure.
A whiff of grapeshot. That’s the ticket.
That, speed and violence.
Update: CDR Salamander has taken note, and if you read carefully between the lines you can tease out his feelings on the matter.
I’m telling you guys, you’ll live a lot longer if you just stop reading the message traffic…
Had two crew mottos during my time as an aircrewman. I’m not sure which I liked more… “We’re the ones your mama warned you about” or “Win or Lose, we booze”.
Either way, the point is that we don’t serve for slogans or speeches. We serve for our shipmates, our family, our country, and ourself.
Really? It’s one of the reasons I scan the traffic, just to find the pearls! (cultural diversity calendars, latest uniform changes, etc.). That and I’m too cheap to subscribe to the (not in my)Navy Times.
I LIKE It!
Print it.
Press on. To Victory.
Subsunk
Relevant to this discussion, the good folks at Big Navy have been good enough to provide a website through which they solicit feedback.
http://www.ethos.navy.mil
Apparently this is open to the active, reserve, and civilian employees of DoN. Requires CAC login to access.
A beauty, it is. Juss wunnerin’, though: how many kids, officer or enlisted, featured on PBS’s CARRIER, would ascribe to this creed?
How ’bout this one:
We Shoot – You Lose
I’ve never been a big fan of the Sailor’s creed. I never learned it . About the only creed I can remember is the doxology and its been years since I had to sing it.
The Navy got along just fine with out them for over 200 years.
It’s garbage like this that has me wondering just what has happened to the Navy. No ships, no planes…nothing but empty slogans.
And I can remember when ADM Hayward was saying, “I’m sick and tired of hearing about ‘the threat’. Let US be the threat!”
Don’t happen to have pic of that Airwing logo do you?
[...] down to that actual oath we take, and personally follows three words, all of which are actually printable. Last I heard, he wasn’t directing formations to recite [...]
blackeagle, I don’t get any Google hits, although I know I saw it on the CAG patch worn by TC Cropper and DCAG Woods on the “Carrier” series.
[...] Yankee Sailor & Phib (especially the comments) Update: See Chap’s and Lex’s posts – Mike weighs in as well. We think we see a trend – wonder if the E-ring [...]
Message Traffic: very good advice….
Lost me at “Active Duty, Reserve, and Civilian Professionals”…
byuck.
I remember two of the ship’s mottos:
“Tis no crime to be stupid, but the stupid shall be punished”
“buddy is only half a word”
Never forget Nose’s favorite:
“A Screwtop only feels sorry for himself.”